Compare
Montale Black Aoud vs Guerlain Rose Amira
Rose Amira is the community's favourite of the two.
Loading comparison...
Notes
———Accords
Rose
100%
Oud
87%
Patchouli
65%
Musky
58%
Woody
56%
Floral
51%
Performance
LongevityEternal
SillageEnormous
Best Seasons
winterfallspring
About
Black Aoud by Montale is a Woody Floral Musk fragrance for men. Black Aoud was launched in 2006. The nose behind this fragrance is Pierre Montale. The fragrance features Rose, Agarwood (Oud), Patchouli, Musk, French labdanum and Mandarin Orange.
vs
Notes
———Accords
Rose
100%
Amber
67%
Patchouli
62%
Warm spicy
57%
Woody
57%
Musky
54%
Performance
LongevityLong lasting
SillageModerate
Best Seasons
winterfallspring
About
Rose Amira by Guerlain is a Oriental Floral fragrance for women and men. Rose Amira was launched in 2024. The nose behind this fragrance is Delphine Jelk. A distinguished rose combining power and gentleness.Rose Amira is a nocturnal tribute to the queen of flowers, an essential scent and perfumery icon. In this journey to the heart of a Persian garden, rose reveals its most sensual fragrance. Shot through with the sacred swirls of frankincense and the warmth of patchouli, the majestic flower unfolds with a blend of strength and softness in a halo of musks.The Allegoria fragrance collection celebrates the wonders of the world. Each creation pays tribute to nature’s beauty and sweeps us up in a discovery of exceptional raw ingredients and notes, beautifully enhanced by our perfumer-explorers. Discover Rose Amira, a nocturnal tribute to the queen of flowers, an essential scent and perfumery icon. In this journey to the heart of a Persian garden, rose reveals its most sensual fragrance. Shot through with the sacred swirls of frankincense and the warmth of patchouli, the majestic flower unfolds with a blend of strength and softness in a halo of musks. "Rose Amira is my vision of rose, sumptuous and sensual within the secrecy of the night. A rose stood upright, turned towards the moon, within a poetic, nocturnal fragrance.” - Delphine Jelk, Guerlain Perfumer Absolus Allegoria, the absolute fragrance collection, is an enchanting and mysterious journey to the heart of the world’s wonders once night falls fragrance trails celebrating deep and powerful nature, revealed by striking contrasts by moonlight. A powerful symbol of Guerlain's commitment to the planet, Absolus Allegoria fragrances contain up to 90% natural origin. The French beetroot alcohol used in their formulas comes from a network committed to responsible farming. Rose Amira comes in the Allegoria collection’s emblematic bottle made in France using 15% recycled glass. Featuring a removable spray pump and transparent lacquer finish, its design can be easily recycled. 90% to 94% of ingredients are of natural origin, by ISO 16128, the calculation includes water.
Rating
3.93vs4.13
Ratings
3,979vs1,085
Concentration
EDPvsEDP
Launch Year
2006vs2024
Which should I buy?
Rose Amira is the community's favourite of the two.
- Rose Amira is rated higher by the community: 4.13 from 1,085 ratings, against 3.93 from 3,979.
- Longevity votes lean "eternal" for Black Aoud and "long lasting" for Rose Amira.
- Sillage votes lean "enormous" for Black Aoud versus "moderate" for Rose Amira.
- Both are voted best for winter and fall.
- Both houses are premium (typically $100–250), so price won't be the deciding factor.
Buy Rose Amira if you want the higher-rated option; pick Black Aoud if its note profile reads closer to what you already love wearing.