
Penhaligon's
Kensington Amber
Premium · $100–250
Shares: vanilla, cedar, cinnamon, labdanum · Differs: bergamot, benzoin, tonka bean

Arquiste
Mid-range · $40–100★ 4.5
We matched 8 fragrances that share J.Crew No. 57's DNA note-by-note, including 2 more-affordable picks — look for the tier badge below.
View full profile →
Penhaligon's
Premium · $100–250
Shares: vanilla, cedar, cinnamon, labdanum · Differs: bergamot, benzoin, tonka bean

Profumum Roma
Mid-range · $40–100
Shares: vanilla, cedar, cinnamon · Differs: sandalwood, tonka bean

M. Micallef
Premium · $100–250
Shares: vanilla, whiskey, cinnamon · Differs: mandarin orange, white musk

Bond No 9
Luxury · $250+
Shares: vanilla, cinnamon, labdanum · Differs: patchouli, amber, musk

By Kilian
Luxury · $250+
Shares: vanilla, cinnamon, oak · Differs: cognac, tonka bean, praline, sandalwood

Lattafa Perfumes
Budget · under $40Mid-range → Budget alternative
Shares: vanilla, whiskey, cedar, oak · Differs: cognac, saffron, nutmeg, apple

Naomi Goodsir
Mid-range · $40–100
Shares: whiskey, cedar, cinnamon, labdanum · Differs: tobacco, amber, incense, oakmoss

Similarity is computed from shared notes and accords — your skin chemistry may vary. Sample links are external; Scentsation may earn a commission.