75%match · #1
Zara
Fierce Love
Budget · under $40Premium → Budget alternative
Shares: tobacco, patchouli, vetiver, tonka bean · Differs: rose water, myrtle
★ 4.0519 ratings
Carolina Herrera
Mystery Tobacco
Premium · $100–250★ 4.4
We matched 8 fragrances that share Mystery Tobacco's DNA note-by-note, including 6 more-affordable picks — look for the tier badge below.
View full profile →
69%match · #2
Caron
L'Heure Vagabonde
Mid-range · $40–100Premium → Mid-range alternative
Shares: ginger, tobacco, patchouli, guaiac wood, vetiver · Differs: lime, bergamot, honey, leather
★ 3.8927 ratings
68%match · #3
Lush
Vegan Leather Jacket
Mid-range · $40–100Premium → Mid-range alternative
Shares: tobacco, vetiver, tonka bean · Differs: cloves
★ 3.9626 ratings
68%match · #4
Aramis
Havana
Mid-range · $40–100Premium → Mid-range alternative
Shares: artemisia, tobacco, patchouli, vetiver · Differs: mandarin orange, basil, caraway, cinnamon
★ 4.261,349 ratings
63%match · #5
Xerjoff
Zanzibar Najaf
Luxury · $250+
Shares: osmanthus, tobacco, patchouli, tonka bean · Differs: agarwood (oud), sandalwood, cedar, green notes
★ 3.81207 ratings
61%match · #6
Rule Fragrances
Rule #7 Bold
Mid-range · $40–100Premium → Mid-range alternative
Shares: patchouli, guaiac wood, vetiver, tonka bean · Differs: grapefruit, lemon, lily, cashmere wood
★ 4.45 ratings
★ 4.43322 ratings
58%match · #8
Guerlain
L’Automne
Premium · $100–250
Shares: citruses, patchouli, vetiver, tonka bean · Differs: iris, cedar, moss
★ 3.0617 ratings
Similarity is computed from shared notes and accords — your skin chemistry may vary. Sample links are external; Scentsation may earn a commission.