Scentsation
Layering Lab

Wear two at once

Pick two fragrances. See what each brings, how the blend leans, and whether people who tried the pair say it works.

Melancholy ThistleFirst · Jo Malone LondonMelancholy ThistleEDP · 2023 · ★ 3.99
Knize SecSecond · KnizeKnize SecEDT · 1985 · ★ 4.13
From your collection:Save fragrances to pick from them here
Melancholy ThistleKnize Sec
Contrast pairing

Melancholy Thistle × Knize Sec

Woody, green and patchouli meets citrus, amber and aromatic. They share one accord and no notes.

Find samples of both
The blend

How the pair leans

Each bar adds the two accord profiles, assuming one spray of each. Gold is Melancholy Thistle, blue is Knize Sec. It's arithmetic on the data, not a test on skin.

Melancholy ThistleKnize Sec
herbalboth
woodyfirst
citrussecond
greenfirst
ambersecond
aromaticsecond
smokysecond
leathersecond
patchoulifirst
freshfirst
What each brings

Notes apart, accords in common

Only in Melancholy Thistle
ThistleThistleIvyIvyWoodsy NotesWoodsy NotesPatchouliPatchouliBroomBroom
In bothNo shared notesOne shared accord:
herbal
That shared thread is what keeps a contrast pairing from feeling like two separate fragrances.
Only in Knize Sec
OrangeOrangeCitrusesCitrusesAmalfi LemonAmalfi LemonCorianderCorianderLavenderLavenderJasmineJasmineSageSagePetitgrainPetitgrainIncenseIncenseLeatherLeatherAmberAmberMuskMusk
Why it might work
  • Light over deepMelancholy Thistle brings green; Knize Sec brings amber. Lighter over deeper is the usual way to layer.
  • A shared threadHerbal runs through both.
  • Opposite seasonsVoters put Melancholy Thistle in spring and Knize Sec in fall. Together they may suit the months in between.
Suggested from the two fragrances' accords, notes and votes. Not yet tested by wearers.
What to watch
  • An unusual mixGreen and amber are often kept apart. Try it on skin before committing.
  • One will leadKnize Sec is voted long lasting and strong; Melancholy Thistle moderate on both. Expect Knize Sec to lead and Melancholy Thistle to fade first.
A starting pointOne spray of Knize Sec, two of Melancholy Thistle over it.Weighted toward the one that fades first. Adjust to taste.
Has anyone tried it?

Be the first to say

No votes on this pair yet. Once 25 people have voted, their verdict leads this page and our suggestion steps back.

Sign in to vote
0 / 25 VOTES
More partners

Other pairings for Melancholy Thistle

Suggested from accords and notes · look-alikes left out
Melancholy Thistle+Une VerveineObviousUne VerveineAdds citrus, aromatic and fresh spicy; shares two accords.ContrastMelancholy Thistle+SalaciousBoadicea the VictoriousSalaciousAdds aromatic, earthy and leather; shares patchouli.ContrastMelancholy Thistle+HyakutakeTiziana TerenziHyakutakeAdds aromatic, citrus and powdery; shares two accords.ContrastBuild your ownPick any two from the catalog ↑
Melancholy Thistle × Knize Sec · Layering Lab | Scentsation