The line, compared

Every Black Phantom, compared

2 fragrances in By Kilian’s Black Phantom line, from 2017 to 2022. Ratings, lasting power and season come from wearers’ votes; accords show what each one adds to the original.

Most worn: Black Phantom10,683 ratings
Highest rated: Black Phantom4.07 of 5
Longest lasting: Black Phantom7.0 of 10

The original

Black Phantom

Launched: 2017
Concentration: Eau de Parfum
Rating: 4.07 · 10,683 ratings
Lasting power: 7.0 of 10
Best in: winter, fall
Most wearers say: unisex

Leads with sweet, warm spicy, caramel.

Black Phantom Memento Mori Anniversary Edition

Launched: 2022
Rating: 3.82 · 188 ratings
Lasting power: 6.1 of 10
Best in: winter
Most wearers say: unisex

Adds woody to the original's profile.