The line, compared

Every New York, compared

2 fragrances in Nicolai Parfumeur Createur’s New York line, from 1989 to 2014. Ratings, lasting power and season come from wearers’ votes; accords show what each one adds to the original.

Most worn: New York Intense1,919 ratings
Highest rated: New York Intense4.26 of 5
Longest lasting: New York Intense6.9 of 10

New York Intense

Launched: 2014
Concentration: Parfum
Rating: 4.26 · 1,919 ratings
Lasting power: 6.9 of 10
Best in: fall, spring
Most wearers say: masculine

Adds herbal to the original's profile.

The original

New York

Launched: 1989
Concentration: Parfum
Rating: 4.17 · 626 ratings
Lasting power: 6.1 of 10
Best in: fall, spring
Most wearers say: masculine

Leads with citrus, aromatic, fresh spicy.