Compare
By Kilian Playing With The Devil vs Nishane Vain Naive
Playing With The Devil is the community's favourite of the two.
Loading comparison...
Notes
Top
Black CurrantWhite PeachLitchiBlood Orange
Heart
PimentoPepperRoseJasmine
Base
VanilaSandalwoodPatchouliCedarBenzoinTonka Bean
Accords
Fruity
100%
Warm spicy
59%
Woody
58%
Citrus
50%
Fresh spicy
49%
Fresh
45%
Performance
LongevityModerate
SillageModerate
Best Seasons
springsummerfall
About
Playing With The Devil by By Kilian is a Oriental Floral fragrance for women. Playing With The Devil was launched in 2013. The nose behind this fragrance is Calice Becker. Top notes are Black Currant, White Peach, Litchi and Blood Orange; middle notes are Pimento, Pepper, Rose and Jasmine; base notes are Vanila, Sandalwood, Patchouli, Cedar, Benzoin and Tonka Bean. "White Collection" In The Garden of Good & Evil by the house of By Kilian presents the fourth edition this year, called Playing With The Devil, inspired by forbidden fruit interpreted in modern, imaginative way. The concept of god and evil is recognized in this composition in which on the one side the creator offers sweet, fruity tamed accord sprinkled with insolence and lecherous heat of resin and hot spices.Composition of Playing with the Devil wins you over at first glance with charm of its zests of litchi, sweet and gently spiced notes of blood orange, black currant and velvety white peach. The sweet fruity start is "shaken" with a spicy blend of pimento and pepper to accentuate the splendor of rose and jasmine flowers in the heart of the composition. The coarser nature is provided to the floral-spicy blend by woody notes of sandalwood, cedar and patchouli that give the depth and darker shades. The composition is again tamed by warm resinous notes of benzoin and smoky tonka, further softened by velvety vanilla. Perfumer who signed the composition is Calice Becker.Playing with the Devil of the collection of In The Garden of Good and Evil is available in a white flacon with golden color details 50ml EDP and in refill flacon 50ml EDP.
vs
Notes
Top
OrangeBergamot
Heart
RaspberryPlumRoseJasmineCedar
Base
SandalwoodTonka BeanMuskAmberPatchouliBenzoin
Accords
Fruity
100%
Sweet
86%
Woody
79%
Amber
65%
Rose
64%
Citrus
60%
Performance
LongevityLong lasting
SillageModerate
Best Seasons
springfallsummer
About
Vain & Naïve by Nishane is a Oriental Floral fragrance for women and men. Vain & Naïve was launched in 2018. The nose behind this fragrance is Chris Maurice. Top notes are Orange and Bergamot; middle notes are Raspberry, Plum, Rose, Jasmine and Cedar; base notes are Sandalwood, Tonka Bean, Musk, Amber, Patchouli and Benzoin. "This scent has been considered to be a tribute to the each “unique love” ever experienced on earth by the creative directors Murat Katran and Mert Guzel. In the novella we see that the prince’s love for his flower causes him much pain and heartbreak. The flower grows from a strange seed that somehow lands up on the prince’s planet. The first thing we learn about her is that she is beautiful. “It is the time you have wasted for your rose that makes your rose so important.” NISHANE’s objective has been to bring the smell of this flower that Little Prince is love with into reality. To be able to bring into existence this coquettish flower that has trouble expressing her love for the little prince and consequently drives him away, NISHANE had to refer to varying notes to underline the mood that is simultaneously vain and naïve. The flower informs the little prince of her love for him too late to persuade him to stay home and not to travel. Throughout the story, she occupies the prince’s thoughts and heart." - a note from the brand.
Notes in Common
35% sharedShared (7)
RoseJasmineSandalwoodPatchouliCedarBenzoinTonka Bean
Only in Playing With The Devil
Black CurrantWhite PeachLitchiBlood OrangePimentoPepperVanila
Only in Vain Naive
OrangeBergamotRaspberryPlumMuskAmber
Rating
3.94vs3.80
Ratings
2,554vs729
Concentration
EDPvsEDP
Launch Year
2013vs2018
Which should I buy?
Playing With The Devil is the community's favourite of the two.
- Playing With The Devil is rated higher by the community: 3.94 from 2,554 ratings, against 3.80 from 729.
- Longevity votes lean "moderate" for Playing With The Devil and "long lasting" for Vain Naive.
- Sillage is comparable: "moderate" is the most common vote for both.
- Both are voted best for spring first.
- Both houses are luxury (typically $250+), so price won't be the deciding factor.
Buy Playing With The Devil if you want the higher-rated option; pick Vain Naive if its note profile reads closer to what you already love wearing.