Penhaligon's The World According to Arthur vs Jo Malone London Scarlet Poppy Cologne Intense

Scarlet Poppy Cologne Intense is the community's favourite of the two.

• ·Scarlet Poppy Cologne Intense is rated higher by the community: 4.27 from 1,137 ratings, against 4.15 from 1,468.
• ·Longevity votes for both lean "moderate".
• ·Sillage is comparable: "moderate" is the most common vote for both.
• ·Both are voted best for winter and fall.
• ·Both houses are premium (typically $100–250), so price won't be the deciding factor.

Buy Scarlet Poppy Cologne Intense if you want the higher-rated option; pick The World According to Arthur if its note profile reads closer to what you already love wearing.