40%similar · #1
Zara
Gardenia
Budget · typically under $40Often for less
Shares: orange blossom, coffee · Differs: vanilla
Compare Black Opium Over Red and Gardenia side by side →
★ 4.011,397 ratings
Yves Saint Laurent
Black Opium Over Red
Premium house · typically $100–250★ 4.25
8 fragrances with similar accords and notes to Black Opium Over Red, including 3 from lower-priced houses.
View full profile →
40%similar · #2
Valentino
Valentino Donna Born in Roma Ivory
Premium · typically $100–250
Shares: green mandarin, orange blossom, madagascar vanilla · Differs: marshmallow, musk
Compare Black Opium Over Red and Valentino Donna Born in Roma Ivory side by side →
★ 3.98994 ratings
37%similar · #3
Zara
Cherry Temptation
Budget · typically under $40Often for less
Shares: cherry, jasmine
★ 3.94110 ratings
36%similar · #4
Zara
Iconic Crush
Budget · typically under $40Often for less
Shares: cherry, jasmine · Differs: lemon, bergamot, vanilla, praline
★ 3.8050 ratings
39%similar · #5
Katana Parfums
Zakhrafa
Shares: cherry, jasmine, coffee · Differs: white flowers, lily of the valley, hazelnut, chocolate
★ 3.7540 ratings
36%similar · #6
Navitus Parfums
Élan Noir
Shares: cherry, orange blossom, madagascar vanilla · Differs: blackcurrant, sour cherry, peach, turkish rose
★ 3.8947 ratings
★ 3.8131 ratings
36%similar · #8
Thameen
Sapphire
Luxury · typically $250+
Shares: green mandarin, jasmine, orange blossom · Differs: cherry blossom, violet, vanilla
★ 3.9314 ratings
Similarity is computed from shared notes (70%) and accords (30%) in our data; it is not a claim that two fragrances smell the same, and your skin chemistry may vary. Price tiers describe each house's typical bottle price, not a specific product. Sample links are external; Scentsation may earn a commission.